Luigi's Pizzeria - Olyphant, PA

https://www.nepapizzareview.com/2020/02/luigis-pizzeria-olyphant-pa.html
Luigi's Pizzeria - Doing Pizza Right in the Mid Valley for Decades
![]() |
Luigi's Pizzeria in Olyphant serves up a classic and consistent NY Style pizza. |
![]() |
The Mid Valley Pizza at Luigi's in Olyphant is topped with a different cheese blend that locals love! |
![]() |
A look under the soft, light, and crisp bottom of a Luigi's Pizza. |
Check out the video to see me and Pizza Ron of We Talk Shirty review all 4 pizzas!
Luigi's pizza sauce is fantastic and the best word I can find for it is vibrant - both in color and flavor. It's naturally sweet, lightly seasoned, and has an intense tomato flavor that stands out and leads the way for each pie. I was really impressed with the sauce!
![]() |
The thick crust Sicilian Pizza at Luigi's Pizza in Olyphant. |
![]() |
The Steak and Cheese double crusted pizza at Luigi's Pizza in Olyphant. |
Finally, the stuffed steak and cheese pizza was a double-crusted pizza stuffed with a blend of cheeses, seasoned sliced and chopped steak, and fried onions. There was so much flavor, the steak was really high in quality and seasoned perfectly, and the cheese blend offered some sharpness, some smoothness, and even a little buttery note. It wasn't greasy at all and wasn't overly filling to eat.
![]() |
Look inside the cheesesteak pizza! |
The Ratings
Restaurant: Luigi's Pizzeria
Location: Olyphant, PA
Date: January 2019
Eat In/Take Out: Eat In
Pizza Ordered: Mid Valley Pizza
Price: $11.99
Crust: 7.9
Sauce: 9.1
Cheese: 8.3
Overall Taste: 8.4
Crispy/Cooked Properly: 7.4
Overall Value: 8.2
Pizza Ordered: NY Style Pizza
Price: $13.58
Crust: 7.9
Sauce: 9.1
Cheese: 7.9
Overall Taste: 8.6
Crispy/Cooked Properly: 7.4
Overall Value: 7.1
Pizza Ordered: Double Crust Steak and Cheese
Price: $15.99
Crust: 7.6
Sauce: N/A
Cheese: 8.2
Overall Taste: 8.3
Crispy/Cooked Properly: 7.5
Overall Value: 7.2
OVERALL RATING: 7.8
Pizza Ordered: Sicilian Pizza
Price: $17.99
Crust: 7.8
Sauce: 9.1
Cheese: 8.2
Overall Taste: 8.3
Crispy/Cooked Properly: 7.5
Overall Value: 7.1