Posts filed under: Pizza Reviews

Pizza Reviews

Local Pizza Reviews by NEPA Pizza Review

Cascarino’s Pizzeria Montgomery NY

Cascarino’s Pizzeria in Montgomery NY served as a pizza oasis on a recent family trip. When traveling on interstate 84 to a lacrosse tournament, there didn’t seem to be many choices for decent local food just off the highway. Until... Read More

Pepperoni Power Rankings – Testing the Best Cup n Char

Pepperoni is the most popular pizza topping. In recent years, cup n char pepperoni has gained popularity in many regions. This type of pepperoni is known for how it curls up and creates what looks like a cup on top... Read More

Shop With Me at Grocery Stores Seeking Best Pizza Ingredients

Come shop with me as I visit local grocery stores to find my favorite pizza ingredients! Throughout my multi-decades long pizza career, I have tested hundreds and hundreds of pizza products. I continue to test pizza ingredients every single week,... Read More

Two Kings Pizza Shickshinny

Two Kings Pizza Shickshinny on West Union Street is a charming pizzeria and restaurant in the heart of town. Recently, I stopped by to review their New York style pizza after many locals advised I should give it a try.... Read More

Polock’s Pizza Nescopeck

Polock’s Pizza in Nescopeck is a legendary spot that people have been telling me to try for years. It’s a tiny little place that operates generally during the winter months a few days a week. In the summer and fall,... Read More

Big Al’s Pizza Berwick

Big Al’s Pizza in Berwick is a small, clean, and simple pizzeria. They feature friendly services and a small menu with simply pizza, stromboli, and calzones. You can dine in at a couple of the small tables, but largely it... Read More

It’s a Utica Thing Utica Tomato Pie Review

What is Utica Tomato Pie? Utica tomato pie is a regional dish popular in Utica, New York, and surrounding areas. It is distinct from traditional pizza in that it typically lacks cheese or has only a minimal amount, and the... Read More

Brasi’s Pizzeria Swoyersville

Brasi’s Pizza in Swoyersville is a small pizza shop that packs a mighty flavor punch. Soon after the pizzeria opened back in 2022 I started receiving messages about how unique and delicious the pizza was. There has been a bit... Read More

Novello’s Pizzeria Scranton

Novello’s Pizzeria in Scranton on West Olive Street is located just across from Scranton High School. It’s in the complex next to Riverfront Sports where Zalewski’s used to operate. The easily accessible pizzeria offers an extensive menu with dine in,... Read More

Bob’s Subs and Pizza Berwick

Bob’s Subs and Pizza in Berwick is a newer spot on West 2nd Street. They are said to have great subs and wings, but I stopped by to check out the pizza. It’s a super clean spot, great to sit... Read More

Fratello’s Pizzeria Italian Kitchen Nescopeck Pizza Review

Fratello’s Pizzeria in Nescopeck is a cozy and comfy little pizzeria and restaurant. They have a small slice case of ready made slices as soon as you walk in. There is also an extensive menu to pick from. I stopped... Read More

Original Pizza on Drinker in Scranton Pizza Review

Original Pizza on Drinker in Scranton is a neat little place that serves a few styles of pizza with their signature sweet sauce. I first learned about the guy behind the pizza when he invited me to his garage to... Read More

Bricktown Pizza Berwick

Bricktown Pizza Berwick opened in the spring of 2023. It’s located in a small pizza shop on West Front Street in Berwick. However, don’t let the small size of the shop think it’s small on flavor! After seeing a few... Read More

Laura’s Pizza and Hoagies Montdale

Laura’s Pizza and Hoagies Montdale is a small shop in a small town. It’s located on the “main drag” in Montdale that consists of just a few small businesses. I’ve long known of Laura’s thanks to consistent reader recommendations that... Read More

City Line Shop Cafe Carbondale Detroit Pizza Review

City Line Shop Cafe Carbondale is a sprawling and unique shop, cafe, restaurant, wine bar and more with rich history. In all my years living in NEPA I had never heard of it before. However, they recently started serving Detroit... Read More

Top 10 Rated Pizzas I Ate in 2023 – NEPA Pizza Review

These are the top 10 rated pizzas I reviewed in 2023! This year was on that found me traveling farther and trying pizzas in new areas inside and out of Northeastern Pennsylvania. Overall, I reviewed 124 pizzas during the calendar... Read More

Original Italian Pizzeria Montrose Pizza Review

Massimo’s Original Italian Pizzeria Montrose is widely recognized as having some of the best pizza in Susquehanna County. The Originial Italian Pizza (OIP) chain is a reliable option for solid pizza in rural areas of Pennsylvania and parts of New... Read More

Scicchitano’s Pizzeria Doagie is a Quirky Berwick Treat

Scicchitano’s Pizzeria Berwick is an old school pizzeria that is famous for their “Doagie” sandwich. The Doagie is something of a round hoagie sandwich made from pizza dough. It comes with everything you’d expect on a hoagie, except that it’s... Read More

Berwick Original Italian Pizza Brooklyn Square and Buffet is Fantastic

Berwick Original Italian Pizza stands out from the rest of the OIP chain for a few reasons. First, they offer a daily pizza buffet! The buffet offers an assortment of different pizzas, stromboli, garlic knots, pasta dishes, and more! It’s... Read More

Green Ridge News Best Gas Station Pizza Review Scranton

Green Ridge News Scranton is a place I’ve driven by many times. It’s an unassuming yet charming little gas station that I never took notice of. That all changed when I put out a facebook post asking readers who makes... Read More